Let My People Think



The “physical death is equivalent to annihilation” viewpoint is held only by a minority of Bible-believing followers of Jesus, we still need to address it. The Scriptures speak of two deaths: of first death (physical) and, in the book of Revelation, of second death. Physical death is what all of us are unfortunately familiar with, and I will address this first.

If physical death was the same as annihilation, then none of the people who died could be resurrected. Nihilo in Latin means “nothing”. Logically speaking, you can’t re-surrect something from nothing. You can’t even re-create something from nothing, since all these verbs prefixed with “re-” imply re-storing something from a diminished condition to a greater condition. Annihilation would mean that the subject can’t be found to exist in any sort of condition, in either physical or any kind of metaphysical realms, period. So no resurrection is possible with this viewpoint (Atheists default to this view, by definition). Without the resurrection of the dead, the whole of Christianity is a moot point, as apostle Paul stated in 1 Cor 15:12-19. That’s as simple of a proof as it gets.

That logic, however, won’t apply to the second death.  C.S. Lewis summed up this predicament quite well in his book “Problem of Pain”:

Whether this eternal fixity implies endless duration – or duration at all – we cannot say.

There have been small wars fought over what the latter means exactly, and those wars were fought with a lot of hostility and acrimony.  For those claiming to be followers of Jesus Christ, that will simply not do. 

That goes for both sides of the debate. My personal impression is that too many of those fights are nothing more than theological bullying and shaming. Many expositions are based not so much on Biblical faithfulness or logic, but rather on protecting the egos vested into certain interpretations. Logical fallacies abound in this area of theological inquiry perhaps more than anywhere else: appeal to human authority / tradition (traditional views), appeals to emotions (non-traditional views), appeal to consequences (both sides), slippery slope (traditional view), “no true Scotsman” (traditional view), appeal to novelty (non-traditional views), and some rather strange appeals to infinity (traditional view). By the way, appealing to infinity is committing a clear category error, which is a type of logical fallacy. Perfection, not infinity, is in question here. I am quite surprised that no major theologian (that I know of) has seriously caught on to this one.

To be sure, differing interpretations of this issue will have potential domino effects on major elements of one’s belief system.  They will also require examining a lot more material than can practically be done in one sitting.  So for now I’ll simply leave this question open for scripturally-based, amicable, and collegial discussion.


Comments on: "Physical death is not equal to annihilation" (3)

  1. lifewithporpoise said:

    wow. This post is where I’m at.

    Questioning the eternal conscious torment doctrine. I realised Annihilation (second death) seemed more likely, as the Scriptures teach resurrection. I’m interested to read more.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Here you mention the physical death as the first death and then the 2nd death being what occurs after the great white throne judgment . When Paul says, we have been crucified with Christ and buried with Christ. Does this fit into a first death? These verses were some of the first which came alive in me to the idea that we are not supposed to die, but are supposed to overcome death.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes – that’s awesome you saw that too!! A lot of New Covenant theology hinges on it – I.e., we are dead to the law, to sin, etc – in a sense that we have experienced part of that first physical death in the body of Jesus, and part of the resurrection ( we have been raised with him, seated with him, etc). The only problem is that our body didn’t participate in it. So we either die and someone raises us up before burial or much later before the last judgment, or we stay alive using our spirit to keep our body alive ( possible in principle, but I don’t know of anyone at that level of spirit mastery ) and get instantly transformed into a glorified when the time comes for that part. But yes – we HAVE died and were raised up. All of that transformation was instant and not perceptible in the physical realm.

      That new birth involved our inner being translocation from fleshly wiring into our spirit, so spirit is our new home base. Hence when ones body dies, the person goes the way of the spirit. When an untransformed person dies physically – they go the way of the flesh, or grave (Sheol / Hades, but without all the Greek baggage).


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Tag Cloud

%d bloggers like this: